yourVINhistory

VIN essentials

A bill of sale for a car proves the deal, not ownership

A bill of sale is a receipt for a car: it names the buyer, the seller, the vehicle, the date and the price. It does not transfer ownership, and it does not satisfy the federal mileage statement, which belongs on the title.

Updated October 29, 2026 · Sources cited below

Have a VIN? Check that car

Find the VIN on the driver's door jamb, at the base of the windshield, or on the registration and insurance card.

View sample report
Hands exchanging a signed document beside a panel of three bill of sale points

THE SHORT ANSWER

A bill of sale is written proof that one named person sold a particular car to another on a given date for a given price. It is evidence, not ownership, because the signed title transfers ownership. Federal odometer rules also place the mileage statement on the title, so a mileage line on a bill of sale is a useful extra record but not the legal disclosure. Whether your state requires one depends on where the car will be titled.

What moves ownership
The signed title, not the bill of sale
Federal mileage statement
Goes on the title under 49 CFR 580.5
Bill of sale in Part 580
The phrase never appears in the rule
Heavy vehicles
Over 16,000 pounds GVWR need no federal mileage statement

Two papers, two different jobs

A private sale usually involves two documents, and they overlap less than people assume. The title is the state's record of who owns the car. The bill of sale is a private record, written by the two of you, saying that a sale took place.

The difference shows up when something goes wrong. A bill of sale with no title signed over to you proves that you paid someone, but a registration office will not accept it as proof of ownership. A signed title with no bill of sale makes you the owner on paper while leaving you with nothing in writing about the price, the date or the terms. Keep both, and keep them together.

Why the mileage line on a template does not count

Downloadable bill of sale forms almost always include an odometer line, and many buyers assume that covers the federal requirement. It does not. The federal odometer rule, 49 CFR Part 580, has the seller state the mileage on the title itself. When the seller is the person named on the title, section 580.5 specifically rules out a separate reassignment form for this.

The words bill of sale do not appear anywhere in the text of Part 580. The rule's stated purpose is to make the mileage statement a condition of getting a title, so the statement lives in the titling paperwork.

Fill in the mileage on your bill of sale anyway. A second dated record in the seller's own handwriting costs nothing. Just make sure the seller also completes the real statement on the title in front of you.

What the federal statement has to contain

Section 580.5 spells out the content. The seller signs and prints a name, and the statement must also include the five items below.

ItemWhat goes in it
MileageOdometer reading when ownership changes, leaving out tenths of a mile
DateThe date the car changes hands
SellerPrinted name and current address
BuyerPrinted name and current address
VehicleMake, model, year, body type and VIN

The seller also certifies the reading: it shows the actual mileage to the best of their knowledge, it has passed the odometer's mechanical limit, or it is not the actual mileage and should not be relied on. The buyer then signs with a printed name, and a copy goes back to the seller. Paper forms must warn that an incomplete or false statement can bring fines or imprisonment.

Vehicles the federal rule leaves out

Section 580.17 excuses some transfers from the mileage statement. These are the ones a private buyer is most likely to meet.

  • Vehicles rated over 16,000 pounds gross weight (GVWR)
  • Vehicles that are not self-propelled, such as trailers
  • Older vehicles, judged by two age tests counted from January 1 of the model year: ten years for the older group of model years and twenty years for the newer group

If an old car's title has no mileage space, the seller is probably not hiding anything. It does mean no federal statement stands behind the odometer, so you need other records to judge the number. The exemption covers only the federal duty. Your state may still want the mileage recorded.

Electronic titles and the lien question

Some states keep titles as electronic records, and Part 580 allows the mileage statement to be made inside that record. There may be no paper title to sign at the sale. The transfer then runs through the state's system, and a paper printout of an electronic record can say outright that it is not the title.

In that setup the bill of sale carries more weight, because it may be the sole document recording who paid what, and when. It is also plainly not enough by itself.

Ask about the lien first

If a lender holds a lien, the seller cannot hand over clear ownership until the loan is paid off, whatever the bill of sale says. Ask whether there is a lien, who holds the title, and how the release will happen before you pay anything.

What to put on the bill of sale

  1. The VIN, read from the car itself. Copy all 17 characters from the plate at the base of the windshield and confirm them against the label on the driver's door jamb.
  2. Printed names and current addresses of both parties, with signatures. A signature nobody can read identifies nobody.
  3. The sale date and the true price. Writing a lower figure to cut the tax is fraud, and it also weakens any claim you might make later.
  4. The odometer reading, labeled as the seller's statement and as a second record.
  5. Any description of the car the seller gave you, worded as what the seller states.
  6. An as-is line, if that is the deal you made.
  7. Both signatures, then one copy for each person.

Check the VIN against everything on the table

The VIN is what turns a pile of paper into a record about one specific car. Compare it on the windshield plate, the door jamb label, the title and the bill of sale. A mismatch between any two is a question to settle before payment, not after. A VIN copied from an online listing carries its typos along, so read it off the car.

NHTSA's public decoder, vPIC, returns the make, model and model year assigned to a VIN, which you can hold against the title. NHTSA's recall lookup shows open recalls for that VIN at no cost, and the NICB VINCheck tool searches theft and salvage records reported by participating insurers. For title brands, odometer readings, liens and accident records, a vehicle history report is the usual route. A free preview of that report on yourvinhistory comes first, and the full report is a one-time purchase.

As-is wording and what it cannot cover

Private-sale bills of sale usually say the car is sold as-is with no warranty. That wording records that you accepted the car in its present condition and that nobody promised how it would run later. It heads off the argument over whether a warranty was expected.

It does not turn a false statement into a true one. An as-is clause speaks to condition, and it generally gives no cover to a seller who gave a wrong mileage or called a branded title clean. So write down what you were told, worded as the seller's claim and dated.

Compare two phrasings. "Seller states the car has not been in an accident" records who said what. "No accident history" has you asserting something you cannot know firsthand. Use the first style for mileage, service history and title status alike.

Required or merely sensible: your state decides

No single sentence covers every state, but the variation follows a pattern.

  • Some states will not process a transfer without a bill of sale.
  • Some want one only if the title lacks a field for the price.
  • Some require notarization, though most do not.
  • Some motor vehicle agencies publish their own form and expect you to use it.
  • Where none of this applies, the bill of sale is still your only written proof of price and date.

The state that matters is the one where the car will be titled, which may not be where you bought it. If that agency publishes a form, use it. It carries the fields its clerks want, in the order they expect, plus any notary block, while a generic template reflects whatever its author guessed was sensible. For that reason this page offers no template.

When the seller will not sign one

A private seller who refuses an ordinary bill of sale is handing you information. There can be innocent reasons, but some patterns deserve attention.

  • The seller will not print a name and address, so you cannot tell who sold you the car.
  • The name on the title differs from the seller's name, so the seller is not the owner, whatever story comes with it.
  • You are asked to leave the price blank or write a lower one, which makes you part of a tax dodge.
  • The VIN is left off or does not match the car.
  • You receive a bill of sale but no signed title, so ownership has not moved.

A mismatched name combined with a missing signed title is the classic sign of curbstoning, where an unlicensed dealer keeps their own name off the paperwork. The documents are where it becomes visible.

What starts ticking after you sign

The date on the bill of sale starts at least two deadlines, and the document satisfies neither. A temporary tag covers driving until permanent plates arrive, and state law sets how long it lasts. Separately, the title must be transferred into your name within a window the state also sets. Meeting one does nothing for the other. Begin the title transfer right away, since processing speed is outside your control.

Before you leave, photograph the title and the bill of sale with the VIN legible on both. If you met somewhere other than the seller's home, write the location on the bill of sale, since which state's rules apply can turn on where the sale happened. Then run the NHTSA recall lookup on the VIN and keep every document in one folder.

Where this information comes from

Sources and photos: Facts checked against the sources above in October 2026. Photo by Annika Wischnewsky on Unsplash; diagrams by YourVINHistory.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

Can I register a car with only a bill of sale?

Usually not. For a car that already has a title, the registration office wants the signed title, and the bill of sale only supports it. Vehicles that have never been titled, or that your state exempts from titling, are handled differently. Ask the agency in the state where you will register before you pay.

Who writes the bill of sale, the buyer or the seller?

Either one can, and the law does not assign the job. What matters is that both sign and both keep a copy. Buyers often do better bringing the form, preferably the state agency's own, because the buyer is the one who will need to produce it at the counter.

Do the buyer and seller both sign the odometer statement?

Yes, in order. The seller signs and prints a name first, then the buyer signs and prints a name. One person cannot sign as both seller and buyer in the same transaction, apart from the power of attorney arrangements the rule itself allows. Where several people own the car, one seller signature is enough.

What if the seller wrote the wrong mileage?

Do not pay yet, and do not cross it out yourself, since an altered title can be rejected. Ask the state motor vehicle agency how mistakes on a title are corrected. Meanwhile compare the figure with service, inspection and past title records, because a wrong number can be an honest slip or a warning sign.

Does a bill of sale protect me from liens or salvage history?

No. It records what the parties said, not what is true. A lien, a theft record or a salvage brand sits in outside records, which the seller may not mention or even know about. Check those records on the VIN before payment, because a signed receipt cannot undo a claim someone else already holds.

Now check the car itself

The guide explains what to look for. The report shows what this VIN has on record.

Find the VIN on the driver's door jamb, at the base of the windshield, or on the registration and insurance card.