yourVINhistory

Years to avoid

Subaru Forester years to avoid: 2014 to 2020 draw the most complaints

Owners have logged 5,042 NHTSA complaints on the Subaru Forester across the 2008 to 2022 model years, and 2019 leads with 831 against a yearly median of 262. The pattern is not a smooth slope: counts stay modest through 2013, jump at 2014 and stay high through 2020.

Updated October 30, 2026 · Sources cited below

Have a VIN? Check that car

Find the VIN on the driver's door jamb, at the base of the windshield, or on the registration and insurance card.

View sample report
Windshield seen from inside a car beside a panel listing three Forester checks

THE SHORT ANSWER

On NHTSA complaint volume, the 2019, 2015 and 2020 Subaru Forester years stand out, with 2019 highest at 831 against a yearly median of 262. Every year from 2014 through 2020 sits above that median, while 2008, 2013 and 2022 are lightest. Visibility / wiper is the largest category at 956 reports. Complaints are unverified owner accounts, not failure rates, so a flagged year means inspect harder.

Complaints on record
5,042 across 2008 to 2022
Median year
262 complaints
Heaviest year
2019, with 831 complaints
Top complaint area
Visibility / wiper, 956 reports

How this Forester ranking is built

Raw complaint totals mostly reflect how many cars were sold and how long they have been driven, so setting the Forester beside another nameplate teaches little. Each model year here is judged against the Forester's own median year instead. Across the 15 model years from 2008 to 2022 that median is 262 complaints, which is exactly the 2010 count. A year at 1× looks ordinary for this SUV, and a year at 3× has drawn about three times the usual volume.

The pool is 5,042 consumer complaints filed with NHTSA. Duplicates were removed by ODI complaint number, and the data was pulled on 2026-08-15, so anything filed later is absent. Recalls are shown beside each year because they measure something else: a recall is a defect the manufacturer has acknowledged, while a complaint is a single owner's unverified account.

All 15 Forester years in one table

The second column puts each ratio into plain words. Light means well under the median, typical means in its neighborhood, elevated means above it, and heavy means more than double.

Model yearReadingTimes the medianComplaintsRecalls
2008Light0.19×501
2009Typical0.68×17818
2010Typical1×26217
2011Typical0.56×14716
2012Light0.4×10515
2013Light0.29×7712
2014Elevated1.54×4032
2015Heavy2.34×6133
2016Elevated1.56×4093
2017Heavy2.21×5801
2018Elevated1.87×4913
2019Heavy3.17×8313
2020Heavy2.27×5940
2021Typical0.79×2070
2022Light0.36×951
Median yearBenchmark1×262n/a

Read the table as two blocks. The 2008 through 2013 years never rise above the median, and the 2014 through 2020 years never drop below it. Only 2021 and 2022 return to the lower half, and those are the youngest cars in the set.

The break between 2013 and 2014

Through 2013 the yearly counts run from 50 to 262, and the highest of them, 2010, only equals the median. Then 2014 arrives with 403 complaints, 1.54× the median, and the next six model years all stay above it. The 2013 figure of 77 and the 2014 figure of 403 sit one year apart, a steep step.

A second step comes between 2018 and 2019, from 491 to 831. A jump that large can follow a redesign or a mechanical change, but it can also come from a bigger sales year, and a complaint count cannot separate the two. For a shopper the practical point is simpler: cars on opposite sides of these steps carry different complaint profiles.

Recalls run the other way. The 2009 to 2013 years carry between 12 and 18 recall entries each, while the 2014 to 2022 years never list more than 3. The 2008 year lists just 1.

The five heaviest years and what tops each list

Five model years run at nearly double the median or more. The complaint area that leads each one is noted beside it.

  • 2019: 831 complaints, 3.17× the median, with visibility / wiper on top
  • 2015: 613 complaints, 2.34×, with engine on top
  • 2020: 594 complaints, 2.27×, visibility / wiper again
  • 2017: 580 complaints, 2.21×, led by air bags
  • 2018: 491 complaints, 1.87×, visibility / wiper once more

Two further years, 2016 at 409 complaints (1.56×) and 2014 at 403 (1.54×), also sit above the median without making the top five. NHTSA lists three recalls on the 2019 year: a power steering connector, a crankcase ventilation valve that can separate and cut engine power, and rear stabilizer bracket bolts that can loosen.

Visibility / wiper mostly means cracked windshields

Across all 15 years, six complaint areas hold most of the volume, and the one on top sounds like a wiper problem.

Complaint areaReports, 2008 to 2022
Visibility / wiper956
Engine740
Electrical system699
Unknown or other699
Air bags661
Power train161

The name misleads. In NHTSA's public complaint database, the entries filed under that heading for 2018, 2019 and 2020 are overwhelmingly about cracked windshields rather than failed wipers. Many owners say nothing struck the glass, some report replacing it more than once, and several place the crack near the rearview mirror mount.

Those narratives are unverified, and a complaint count does not show why glass cracks. It does show where a Forester buyer should look first.

Engine in 2015, air bags in 2017

Engine is the second-largest area at 740 reports and leads the 2015 year, the second heaviest overall. NHTSA lists a recall on certain turbocharged XT Foresters built between April and October 2015, where the turbocharger air intake duct can crack and stall the engine. The 2015 complaint text also contains accounts of oil consumption, power loss and sudden surging, which a service history should either confirm or rule out.

Air bags total 661 reports and lead 2017. The recall list explains part of it: NHTSA records a campaign on 2015 to 2018 Foresters with heated seats, where an electrical connection under the front passenger seat for the occupant detection system can loosen. The passenger air bag may then switch off even with someone sitting there. Dealers inspect and replace the sensor harness at no charge under that campaign. A few owners say the warning light returned after the repair, which is one reason to test it yourself.

Why 2009 to 2013 show so many recalls

A year can list many recalls and still draw few complaints, which usually means problems were found and repaired before owners had much to report. The 2009 to 2013 Foresters fit that pattern: 12 to 18 recalls each, yet no complaint count above the median. A large share of the entries in NHTSA's list for those years are passenger-side air bag inflator campaigns, and the rest include an ignition switch, brake hoses and seat belts.

Open items matter more than the count. Each campaign applies only to a production range, so run the VIN through NHTSA's recall lookup and ask for proof of completion. Federal law ends the maker's duty to repair at no charge for vehicles first bought more than 15 calendar years before the notice or order, under 49 U.S.C. §30120(g). On the oldest cars, ask a dealer in advance what a newly announced campaign would cost you.

The quietest settled years

Four model years sit well under the median.

  • 2008: 50 complaints, 0.19× the median, 1 recall
  • 2013: 77 complaints, 0.29×, 12 recalls
  • 2022: 95 complaints, 0.36×, 1 recall
  • 2012: 105 complaints, 0.4×, 15 recalls

Treat 2022 with care. It is the youngest year in the table, so some of its quiet record is simply age, and 2021 at 207 complaints (0.79×) has the same caveat. The 2012 and 2013 cars look light on complaints but carry long recall lists, so the VIN lookup matters most there. On a Forester this old, maintenance history says more about the car than any model-year statistic.

What to check on a Forester from a flagged year

Treat the flag as a checklist rather than a reason to walk away. Taken in the order a walk-around and test drive usually run:

  1. Look through the windshield in daylight, scanning the edges and the area around the mirror mount, and ask whether the glass is original.
  2. Request receipts for any glass replacement and find out how many times it has been done.
  3. On a 2015 to 2018 car with heated seats, seat a passenger in front with the ignition on and watch the passenger air bag indicator.
  4. On a turbocharged 2015 or 2016 XT, confirm the turbocharger duct campaign was completed, then listen for hesitation or stalling on a drive.
  5. Check the oil level and ask how often it has been topped up, since oil consumption appears in the 2015 narratives.
  6. Run the VIN through NHTSA's recall lookup and get paperwork for each repair that was done.
  7. Book a pre-purchase inspection on a lift with a mechanic who earns nothing from the sale.

Electrical system and unknown or other complaints each reach 699 reports, so ask the mechanic to scan for stored fault codes as well.

From model year to the car in front of you

A model year describes a population. Recalls attach to production ranges, while title status, odometer readings and past damage belong to one vehicle. After the recall lookup, check the national title record through NMVTIS and screen the VIN for theft and total-loss reports with NICB's VINCheck, a no-cost tool. A vehicle history report from this site gathers title brands, accident records and odometer readings in one document; a preview by VIN comes first, and the full report is a paid, one-time purchase.

Flag, not verdict

Every year in the table includes well-kept cars and neglected ones. A heavy year is a reason to inspect harder and ask for records, and it can justify a lower offer when the checks turn up work still to be done.

Where this information comes from

  • NHTSA: Vehicle safety — Home of the public complaint database behind the owner reports counted in this ranking.
  • NHTSA: Recalls — The recall lookup by VIN, and the campaign records behind each year's recall count.
  • Bureau of Justice Assistance: NMVTIS — Federal overview of the national title database, which covers the title history of one car.
  • NICB: VINCheck — A no-cost screen for reported theft and total-loss status on a single VIN.

Sources and photos: Facts checked against the sources above in October 2026. Photo by Cole Keister on Unsplash; diagrams by YourVINHistory.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

Which Subaru Forester years should I avoid?

Be most cautious with 2019, 2015, 2020, 2017 and 2018, which run from 1.87× to 3.17× the Forester's median of 262 complaints. Caution means inspecting harder and asking for records, not refusing to look. A well-kept 2019 with a sound windshield and completed recalls can beat a neglected car from a quieter year, and the 2016 and 2014 years also sit above the median.

Which Subaru Forester years have the fewest complaints?

Among older years, 2008 and 2013 are lightest at 0.19× and 0.29× the median, with 2012 at 0.4×. The 2022 year at 0.36× is the youngest in the table, so part of that quiet record is age. Complaint counts also cannot measure reliability, so use them to decide which cars to inspect first, not to certify one.

What do Subaru Forester owners complain about most?

By NHTSA category it is visibility / wiper at 956 reports, and the entries for 2018 through 2020 are mostly about cracked windshields rather than wipers. Engine follows at 740 reports. These are broad categories chosen by owners, so they show where complaints land, not which part failed or how often.

Is a Forester with many recalls a bad buy?

Not by itself. A recall means the maker acknowledged a defect, and the 2009 to 2013 years list 12 to 18 of them while drawing few complaints. What counts is whether each campaign on that VIN was completed. Dealers repair recalls at no charge only within federal limits, including a cutoff for vehicles first bought more than 15 calendar years before the notice.

How do I check a specific Forester before buying?

Start with the 17-character VIN. Run NHTSA's recall lookup, then check the NMVTIS title record and NICB's VINCheck for theft and total-loss reports. A vehicle history report adds accident and odometer records, and a pre-purchase inspection on a lift covers what no database can see, such as glass condition, oil level and seat sensor behavior.

Now check the car itself

The guide explains what to look for. The report shows what this VIN has on record.

Find the VIN on the driver's door jamb, at the base of the windshield, or on the registration and insurance card.