yourVINhistory

Repair costs

Subaru Forester head gasket replacement cost: the engine decides the bill

RepairPal's published estimates for a Forester head gasket run from $2,000 to $4,000, and most of the money is labor, because the boxer engine sits low and tight in the bay. Before you accept a quote, find out which engine the car has: the gasket reputation belongs to the EJ25 through 2010, while the 2011 to 2014 FB25 had an oil-consumption fault whose repair happens to include new head gaskets.

Updated October 30, 2026 · Sources cited below

Have a VIN? Check that car

Find the VIN on the driver's door jamb, at the base of the windshield, or on the registration and insurance card.

View sample report
Mechanic inspecting a car beside a panel listing three Forester head gasket checks

THE SHORT ANSWER

Expect $2,572 to $3,386 on RepairPal's general head gasket estimator, or $2,000 to $4,000 on its Forester-specific page, with labor the larger share. The classic gasket weakness is the EJ25 engine in non-turbo Foresters through 2010. Foresters from 2011 to 2014 carry the FB25, whose documented fault is oil consumption, repaired under Subaru bulletin 02-157-14R. No NHTSA recall names a Forester head gasket.

RepairPal estimator
$2,572 to $3,386, before taxes and fees
RepairPal Forester page
$2,000 to $4,000 average
EJ25 years in the complaint tally
9% of Forester engine reports
Oil bulletin labor
11.5 to 12.0 hours, short block

Two published ranges, and who stands behind them

This site sells vehicle history reports, not repairs, so every dollar figure below belongs to RepairPal and was read from its pages in October 2026. RepairPal says its general range excludes taxes, fees or local rates, and a separate Forester page shows a wider average.

LineRepairPal figure
General estimator, total$2,572 to $3,386
Labor inside that total$1,669 to $2,449
Parts inside that total$903 to $937
Forester page, average$2,000 to $4,000

Forum and social posts quote their own bills, but those could not be verified at the source, so none appear here. Treat RepairPal's numbers as a yardstick for a quote, not a price measured in your town.

Why labor takes the biggest slice

Subaru builds every Forester engine as a flat, horizontally opposed four, which puts the two cylinder heads out at the sides of the block, low against the frame rails. Shops commonly lift the whole engine out to reach them properly, which is why labor is the larger line in RepairPal's split.

Subaru's labor clock gives a sense of scale: bulletin 02-157-14R books 11.5 to 12.0 hours for a short block swap, which means pulling the engine and both heads. A gaskets-only job skips the block itself but needs much the same access.

Find the engine before you price anything

The Forester name has covered two different 2.5-liter engines, and the risk and the bill differ between them.

YearsEngineWhat the documents say
2008 to 2010, non-turboEJ25, single overhead cam, belt-drivenThe home of the head gasket reputation
2011 onward, non-turboFB25, chain-drivenSubaru documented oil consumption for 2011 to 2014, fixed with a short block

The turbo XT is trickier: its engine stayed in the EJ family until the 2014 redesign, so XT models from 2011 to 2013 go with the older story. A VIN decode that reports the engine settles which car you have.

What a complete EJ25 quote should itemize

Two quotes for one Forester can land far apart because they price different jobs. Ask for these lines.

Quote lineReason to ask
Engine pulled or left in the carHours change sharply, so learn which one the price assumes
Head flatness check and machiningA warped head leaks again under a new gasket
Timing belt, idlers, water pumpThe belt comes off to free the heads, so shops replace it
Coolant, conditioner and oilSubaru's own repair parts list names coolant and Cooling System Conditioner

The belt line is where quotes for one EJ25 job diverge. Some shops fold in a full timing service, while others quote the gaskets only and defer the belt to a later visit, which means paying for the same teardown twice.

Seep or internal failure: the diagnosis sets the urgency

A shop that says "head gasket" should be able to say what it actually saw.

What the shop reportsWhat it usually meansHow urgent
Oil film on the bottom edge of a headExternal oil seepSlow, but it tends to worsen
Crusted coolant where head meets blockExternal coolant seepWatch level and gauge
Coolant vanishing with no leak, bubbles in the reservoirInternal, combustion gas in the coolantTest before driving further
Overheating, white exhaust or milky oilInternal failureStop driving

External seeps are the classic EJ25 pattern, and some owners run them for months while watching both fluids. A motor that repeatedly overheats can warp the heads and turn a gasket job into something larger. An FB25 that loses oil with a dry engine points to the bulletin below, not a gasket.

2011 to 2015: an oil bulletin that lists head gaskets, and a settlement that ended

Subaru Service Bulletin 02-157-14R dates from August 2014 and was last revised in 2018. It applies to 2011 to 2014 Foresters with the 2.5L FB engine and to 2015 Foresters with a manual transmission. Once a dealer's test shows the engine using over one-third of a quart across 1,200 miles, the remedy is a new short block.

The confusion is easy to understand. A short block job takes out the engine and both heads, and the bulletin's parts table lists head gaskets beside coolant and conditioner, so a 2012 or 2014 invoice can show new gaskets when the fault was piston rings. Later 2014 automatics and later 2015 manuals got redesigned rings from certain VINs and are not on the list.

A class action over the same oil problem ended in a 2016 settlement. Subaru's retailer notice covers 2011 to 2014 automatics and CVTs below VIN *529004 and 2011 to 2015 manuals below VIN *543650. Powertrain coverage for excessive oil consumption stretched to 8 years or 100,000 miles, cash claims were due by October 1, 2016, and Subaru denied that the cars were defective. Eight years of service have since elapsed for every car on that list.

What 5,042 federal complaints say about the engine

NHTSA's complaint file, tallied for Foresters from 2008 through 2022, holds 5,042 reports; 740 sit under ENGINE, which ranks in the top five components in all 15 model years. Because NHTSA has no head gasket category, ENGINE also holds misfires, mounts and oil consumption, so 740 is a ceiling on gasket trouble, never a count of it.

Model yearsEngine reportsShare of the 740Engine share of that group's complaints
2008 to 2010 (EJ25)689%14%
2011 to 2014 (bulletin years)18225%25%
2015 and laterBusiest year: 131, in 201566%13%

Raw counts rise with the number of cars still driving from each model year, so the last column says more. Engine reports are 41% of everything filed against the 2011 car, the peak, and settle at 13% from 2015 on. The bulge sits in the oil years, not the gasket years.

2008 to 2010: where the reputation fits, narrowly

Across the three EJ25 model years, engine reports numbered 7, 27 and 34. A text search of complaint narratives for "head gasket" found matches clustered in these cars, with scattered mentions afterward.

Two cautions apply. ENGINE is a broad bucket, so plenty of those reports are not gaskets. And the reputation predates the data: most of the EJ25's gasket history belongs to cars from 1999 to 2007, which this tally leaves out. Secondhand accounts mention a late-1990s Subaru program, WWP-99, that added conditioner for slow coolant seeps; no original document turned up, and no extension covering head gaskets on a 2008 to 2010 Forester was found.

2016 to 2022: no document names the gasket

The second bump on the engine chart, around 2015 and again near 2019, can look like gaskets returning, but the record does not say so. The 2015 car has the most engine reports of any year and sits at the edge of the oil bulletin's reach. The 2019 and 2020 rise coincides with the redesigned Forester and its direct-injected FB25. No Subaru document and no NHTSA recall found names a head gasket on any 2016 to 2022 car.

None of this makes a late Forester gasket-proof. An engine that ran hot, ran low on coolant or got the wrong coolant can lift a gasket, so the cooling history is the clue, not the model year.

Recalls, extensions, bulletins and goodwill: who pays for what

Searching NHTSA's recall records for 2008 through 2022 Foresters finds no campaign naming a head gasket. Three involve the engine: 08V460000 (certain 2009 Foresters, a turbocharger oil supply pipe assembled incorrectly), 16V162000 (certain 2015 to 2016 Forester 2.0XT models, a turbo intake duct that may crack) and 19V856000 (certain 2019 models, a PCV valve that can come apart).

ProgramWhat it pays for
RecallSafety defects only, repaired at no charge within the federal rule's limits
Warranty extension (02-157-14R)Oil consumption alone, up to 8 years or 100,000 miles after warranty start
Service bulletinSupplies repair steps and labor times, pays nothing outside warranty
GoodwillDiscretionary, usually near the end of the factory warranty

Run the VIN through NHTSA's recall lookup anyway; several Forester years carry open campaigns on other systems.

Before you authorize the job, or buy the car

  • Get the engine from the VIN: EJ25 or FB25, and whether it is a turbo XT
  • Ask which leak the shop found and which test showed it
  • On a thirsty FB25 with a dry engine, ask for the oil consumption test result
  • On an EJ25, ask whether the quote includes the belt, idlers and water pump
  • Ask if the shop will measure the heads for warping and resurface them when needed

If you are buying, the record works as a shopping map. On a 2008 to 2010 Forester, ask for paperwork showing the gaskets and belt were done; without it, price the car as though they were not. On a 2011 to 2015 car, ask whether a short block went in under 02-157-14R, and read the dipstick yourself. A yourvinhistory.com report lists the factory engine and open recalls for a VIN, which handles the first check before you visit. Then look along the lower edge of each head with a flashlight, and have an independent pre-purchase inspection pressure-test the cooling system.

Where this information comes from

Sources and photos: Facts checked against the sources above in October 2026. Photo by Mustafa Sheikhmouss on Unsplash; diagrams by YourVINHistory.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

How much does it cost to replace a Subaru Forester head gasket?

On RepairPal's estimator the general range is $2,572 to $3,386, while its Forester page averages $2,000 to $4,000, both before taxes and fees. Compare quotes line by line: an EJ25 price that omits the timing belt and water pump covers a smaller job than one that bundles them.

Which Subaru Forester years have head gasket problems?

Mostly EJ25 cars: that engine, used in non-turbo Foresters through 2010, is where the reputation comes from, and the 2008 to 2010 cars hold 9% of the engine complaints in a 2008 to 2022 tally. From 2011 the FB25 took over, and Subaru's documented fault for 2011 to 2014 was oil consumption. Nothing found names a gasket on 2016 to 2022 cars.

Can I keep driving a Forester with a bad head gasket?

It depends on the kind of leak. A slow external seep can sometimes be monitored if you check oil and coolant often and the gauge stays normal. Vanishing coolant with no puddle, bubbles in the reservoir, white exhaust or overheating points inside the engine, and driving on can warp the heads. Have the system pressure-tested and the coolant checked for exhaust gas first.

Will Subaru pay for a Forester head gasket?

Probably not. No recall or extension names the head gasket. The one extension, tied to bulletin 02-157-14R, covers oil consumption for eight years or 100,000 miles from the warranty start, a window every eligible Forester has now passed. Goodwill help is possible near the end of a factory warranty, at Subaru's and the dealer's discretion.

Is a 2016 or 2017 Forester a head gasket risk?

Neither year shows a documented pattern. Both use the FB25, and no Subaru bulletin, extension or NHTSA recall found for them names the head gasket. The complaint tally has 60 engine reports for 2016 and 46 for 2017, across every kind of engine concern. If one overheats, its cooling history matters more than its model year.

Now check the car itself

The guide explains what to look for. The report shows what this VIN has on record.

Find the VIN on the driver's door jamb, at the base of the windshield, or on the registration and insurance card.