
THE SHORT ANSWER
Judged by NHTSA complaint volume, the Soul years to inspect hardest are 2015, 2014 and 2016. Every model year from 2012 through 2016 sits above the Soul's own median of 288, and engine is the leading complaint area by a wide margin at 3,063 reports. The lightest records belong to 2022, 2010 and 2019. A complaint count is not a failure rate, so treat a flagged year as a cue to check one car closely.
- NHTSA complaints
- 5,426 across 2010 to 2022
- Benchmark year
- 288 complaints (the median)
- Highest year
- 2015, with 902 complaints
- Largest area
- Engine, 3,063 reports
How this ranking is built
Raw complaint totals mostly reveal how many cars were sold. A popular model year piles up reports because more of them are on the road, so setting the Soul beside a rarer car proves little. The yardstick here is the Soul itself: across its 13 model years the median year logged 288 complaints, and every year is expressed as a multiple of that figure.
The counts come from NHTSA's consumer complaint database for model years 2010 through 2022, de-duplicated by complaint number and pulled in August 2026. They add up to 5,426 reports. A multiple near 1× marks an ordinary Soul year, while a multiple near 3× means owners filed about three reports for each one in an ordinary year.
Two limits apply throughout. Each complaint is one owner's unverified account, and older model years have had longer to collect them. Neither the counts nor the multiples amount to a failure rate or a reliability score.
All 13 model years in one table
Standing is a plain-word label for each multiple of the median. Recalls are the number of recall campaigns NHTSA lists against that model year.
| Model year | Standing | Multiple of median | Complaints | Recalls |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2010 | Light | 0.47× | 134 | 3 |
| 2011 | Typical | 0.67× | 193 | 3 |
| 2012 | Heavy | 1.78× | 514 | 3 |
| 2013 | Very heavy | 2.29× | 660 | 3 |
| 2014 | Very heavy | 3.1× | 894 | 5 |
| 2015 | Very heavy | 3.13× | 902 | 4 |
| 2016 | Very heavy | 2.8× | 805 | 2 |
| 2017 | Typical | 1× | 288 | 1 |
| 2018 | Typical | 0.75× | 216 | 1 |
| 2019 | Light | 0.48× | 137 | 1 |
| 2020 | Typical | 1.28× | 369 | 1 |
| 2021 | Typical | 0.78× | 226 | 2 |
| 2022 | Light | 0.31× | 88 | 1 |
| Median of all years | Benchmark | 1× | 288 | not scored |
The median happens to equal the 2017 count exactly, which is why that year reads 1×.
The five heavy years, 2012 through 2016
Five model years in a row run above the median, and in every one of them engine is the most-reported component. 2015 and 2014 are nearly tied at the top, at 902 and 894 complaints, or 3.13× and 3.1× the median. 2016 follows at 805 and 2.8×.
A step down brings 2013 at 660 complaints and 2.29×, then 2012 at 514 and 1.78×. Recall counts echo the shape: 2014 carries 5, the highest in the table, 2015 carries 4, and 2012 and 2013 carry 3 each, with 2016 at 2.
None of this makes a particular 2015 Soul a bad car. It means more owners of these years had something to report, so the inspection should go deeper and the price should account for any work still open.
Where the curve bends: up in 2012, down in 2017
Plotted by model year, the Soul's complaint count looks like a hill. The first two years are light, with 134 for 2010 and 193 for 2011. Then 2012 jumps to 514, the count keeps climbing through 660 and 894, peaks at 902 in 2015, and slips to 805 in 2016.
The drop that follows is just as sharp. 2017 lands on 288, and 2018 and 2019 go lower still, at 216 and 137. One later year breaks the pattern: 2020 reaches 369, or 1.28×, before 2021 falls back to 226 and 2022 to 88. Even the 2020 figure sits well under the counts for 2012 through 2016.
A break this large often follows a design or mechanical change, but NHTSA's counts do not say what changed on the Soul at either bend, and this page will not guess. What the shape does give a shopper is a sorting step: confirm a car's model year from its VIN, then note which side of 2012 and of 2017 it falls on before reading anything else about it.
The lightest records: 2022, 2010 and 2019
Among settled model years, three carry the smallest complaint records against the median.
- 2022: 88 complaints, 0.31× the median, 1 recall
- 2010: 134 complaints, 0.47×, 3 recalls
- 2019: 137 complaints, 0.48×, 1 recall
The ranking keeps the newest model years out of its cleanest list on purpose, since a car with little time on the road has had little time to draw reports. All 13 Soul years here count as settled, but 2022 is still the youngest, so part of its low count may simply reflect youth. 2010 is the oldest year in the table and still reads light, which carries more weight, though its 3 recalls deserve a lookup. If none of the three fits the budget, 2018 and 2021 sit below the median at 0.75× and 0.78×, and 2017 sits exactly on it.
What owners report: engine far ahead
NHTSA files each complaint under a component category. Added up across all 13 model years, the Soul's totals run as follows.
| NHTSA category | Reports, 2010-2022 |
|---|---|
| Engine | 3,063 |
| Unknown or other | 518 |
| Electrical system | 455 |
| Power train | 361 |
| Steering | 344 |
| Service brakes | 205 |
The labels are broad. Engine covers any engine fault, not one part. Electrical system takes in batteries, wiring, lighting and control modules. Power train includes the transmission and related components. So the counts show a mechanic where to look, not which part failed, and the category data does not reveal what Soul owners described inside the engine group. Engine leads in all five heavy years, and in 2015 the unknown-or-other bucket stands out as well.
Reading the numbers without being misled
- Sales volume: a high seller piles up more reports than a scarce car of equal quality, so each year is scaled to the Soul's own median.
- Age: older model years have had longer to accumulate reports, so the newest are kept out of the cleanest list instead of being praised.
- Source: a complaint records what an owner believed happened. That is useful in bulk and shaky one report at a time.
- Scope: the table describes a group of cars, never the one you are about to buy.
Use the flag to inspect, not to dismiss
Every model year holds well-kept cars and neglected ones. A flagged year earns a longer inspection and a firmer price, not an automatic pass.
Recalls, and the 15-year limit on no-charge repairs
A recall is a different kind of evidence from a complaint. It is a defect the manufacturer has acknowledged and must repair at no charge to the owner, rather than one unconfirmed report. A year can show many recalls and modest complaints, which can mean problems were caught and repaired early. Years that show both, like 2014 and 2015, need their recall list read line by line.
The no-charge promise has an age limit. Under 49 U.S.C. 30120(g), a manufacturer is not required to remedy a vehicle at no charge when the first purchaser bought it more than 15 calendar years before the recall notice. On an older Soul, who pays for an open campaign can differ from what the newer cars get, so ask the dealer before you count on it.
Recalls also attach to production ranges rather than whole model years, so a model-year count cannot tell you whether a given Soul is affected. NHTSA's recall lookup answers that by VIN and costs nothing to use.
What to check on a used Soul from a heavy year
Take this list to any Soul, but spend the most time on it for 2012 through 2016.
- Run the 17-character VIN through NHTSA's recall lookup and keep the printout. Open campaigns attach to production ranges, so only the VIN answers for this car.
- Ask for maintenance records and read them for oil changes and any engine work. On a compact this old, a paper trail says more than a model-year table can.
- Have a mechanic examine the engine on a lift: oil level and condition, leaks, noises on a cold start, stored codes and warning lights.
- Test the electrical side by working the windows, locks, lights and anything run by a control module, and check how the battery behaves.
- Drive it for steering and transmission behavior: pulling, looseness, noise, hesitation or rough shifts. Press the brake pedal hard and note how it feels.
- Use whatever turns up in price talks, and walk away if the problem is more than minor.
Checks a model-year ranking cannot make
A model year is a population. Title, odometer and damage history belong to a single car, and that car's record can contradict everything in the table above. Three lookups cover the ground a year ranking leaves open.
- NHTSA's recall lookup, run by VIN, for open campaigns.
- NICB's VINCheck, which costs nothing, for theft and total-loss flags on the VIN.
- A title check against NMVTIS, the national title-record system, for the car's title history and brands.
A yourvinhistory report pulls title brands, accident records with a damage map, odometer readings, salvage and auction records, liens, theft and open recalls into one document. Its title records come from ClearVin LLC, an approved NMVTIS data provider. A preview comes first, and the full report is a one-time purchase.
Where this information comes from
- NHTSA: Vehicle safety and complaints — The complaint database behind every per-year and per-component count in this article.
- NHTSA: Recalls — Where open campaigns for one VIN can be looked up, something a model-year count cannot replace.
- BJA: National Motor Vehicle Title Information System — The federal title-record system behind brand and salvage checks on one specific car.
- NICB: VINCheck — A theft and total-loss screen for a single VIN, offered at no cost.
Sources and photos: Facts checked against the sources above in October 2026. Photo by Nik on Unsplash; diagrams by YourVINHistory.
Keep reading
- 2015 Kia Soul recalls and engine complaints: what to checkThe peak year's own page, with its recall campaigns and the components owners filed against.
- Recall check by VINThe step to run first on any Soul: checking open recalls for the exact VIN.
- Kia engine warrantyEngine leads the Soul's complaints, so see how a Kia engine warranty extension is checked by VIN.
- Pre-purchase inspectionWhat a mechanic's inspection covers before you hand over money on a flagged year.
Frequently asked questions
Which Kia Soul years should I avoid?
Start with 2015, 2014 and 2016, which draw the most NHTSA complaints against the Soul's own median, then 2013 and 2012. Engine is the top-reported area in all five. Avoid is a strong word, though. A documented service history and a clean VIN-level check can make a car from any of these years a fair buy, while a neglected car from a quiet year is not.
What is the best Kia Soul year to buy used?
On complaints alone, the lightest records belong to 2022, 2010 and 2019, with 2022 the youngest and so the least tested. For a middle path, 2018 and 2021 sit below the median at 0.75× and 0.78×. Complaint counts cannot rank reliability, and how the individual car was maintained still outweighs the badge year.
What goes wrong most often on a Kia Soul?
On the NHTSA record, engine, by a wide gap: 3,063 reports against 518 filed as unknown or other and 455 under electrical system. The category covers any engine fault, so it points a mechanic at the engine bay without naming a part. Ask for engine service history on any Soul, whatever the year.
Does a high complaint count make a Soul a bad car?
Not by themselves. Counts rise with sales and with time on the road, and every one is an unverified owner account, which is why each year here is scaled to the Soul's own median. A count also describes a whole model year. The car you are test driving gets answered by its VIN records and an inspection.
How do I confirm which year a Kia Soul is?
Read it from the VIN, which appears on the title and registration and on the dashboard plate visible through the windshield. The tenth of the 17 characters is the model-year code. Matching that code to the year matters here because the Soul's complaint counts change sharply between 2011 and 2012 and again between 2016 and 2017.
Now check the car itself
The guide explains what to look for. The report shows what this VIN has on record.