yourVINhistory

Years to avoid

Chevrolet Silverado 1500 years to avoid: 2014, 2015 and 2019 stand out

Measured against the truck's own yearly median of 826 NHTSA complaints, the 2014, 2015 and 2019 Silverado 1500 stand out, with 2014 heaviest at 1,606. The 2012 model year has the lightest record at 359, and the full 2008 to 2022 run holds 12,743 owner complaints.

Updated October 30, 2026 · Sources cited below

Have a VIN? Check that car

Find the VIN on the driver's door jamb, at the base of the windshield, or on the registration and insurance card.

View sample report
Brake caliper and drilled disc with wheel beside a NHTSA complaint ranking summary panel

THE SHORT ANSWER

On NHTSA complaint volume, the 2014, 2015 and 2019 model years stand out, with 1,606, 1,405 and 1,151 complaints against a median of 826 for any single year. 2012 has the lightest record at 359. Engine is the largest complaint area over the whole run. Complaints are unverified owner accounts, not failure rates, so a flagged year means inspect harder and bargain, not walk away.

Complaints on record
12,743 across 2008 to 2022
Median year
826 complaints
Heaviest year
2014, with 1,606 complaints
Lightest year
2012, with 359 complaints

How each year is measured against its own truck

Raw complaint totals mostly reveal which years sold in the largest numbers. To soften that, each Silverado 1500 model year from 2008 through 2022 is set against the middle value of the 15 years, which is 826 complaints. A year at twice that figure drew about twice the reports of the typical Silverado year; a year at half drew about half.

The counts come from NHTSA owner complaints, deduplicated on the complaint number and pulled on 2026-08-15, and they total 12,743 for the run. Each one is a single owner's unverified account. That makes the totals a rough map of attention, not a failure rate or a reliability score, and nothing here measures how many owners never filed at all.

All 15 model years in one table

Standing is a plain label taken from the multiple. Three years read high, one reads low, and the rest sit in the ordinary range. The 2020 year lands exactly on the median because its own count of 826 is the median.

YearOwner complaintsTimes the medianRecalls talliedStanding
20081,0761.3×2Typical
20095910.72×0Typical
20104450.54×1Typical
20117710.93×2Typical
20123590.43×2Low
20134420.54×3Typical
20141,6061.94×14High
20151,4051.7×7High
20169741.18×2Typical
20179031.09×0Typical
20185860.71×0Typical
20191,1511.39×0High
20208261×0Typical, the median itself
20219071.1×0Typical
20227010.85×0Typical

Read the recall column with the caution given further down. It is a tally from one data pull, not NHTSA's live list.

The cliff between 2013 and 2014

Look at the rows on either side of one line. Owners filed 442 complaints on 2013 trucks and 1,606 on 2014 trucks, and the recall tally climbs from 3 to 14 at the same point. Nothing else in the run moves that far in one step. A jump of that size usually signals a redesign or a change to major mechanical parts, not slow wear, so the first question about any Silverado from around then is which side of the line it falls on.

The VIN settles it. Positions 4 through 8 describe model, body and engine, and position 10 carries the model year, so a decoded build shows what the truck really has instead of what the listing claims.

A smaller version appears later. Complaints go from 586 for 2018 to 1,151 for 2019, then fall back to 826 for 2020. One high year between two ordinary ones looks like a bump tied to that model year rather than an effect of age.

The three years above the line: 2014, 2015 and 2019

Each flagged year has its own leading complaint area.

  • 2014: 1,606 complaints, 1.94 times the median and the heaviest year of the run. Steering leads, and the electrical system also stands out.
  • 2015: 1,405 complaints, 1.7 times the median. Service brakes lead.
  • 2019: 1,151 complaints, 1.39 times the median. Engine leads.

Those are leading areas, not the only ones. For 2014 trucks, NHTSA's own recall listing names campaigns touching the electric power steering assist, brake power assist and anti-lock system, front air bags and front seat belts. A complaint is not a recall and neither proves the other. Still, steering appearing on both lists for 2014 is a reason to confirm that every campaign was actually performed on a truck from that year.

The lightest year, and the near misses

Only 2012 earns the low label. Its 359 complaints are the smallest count of the 15 years, 0.43 times the median, and the recall tally gives it 2. Two more years come close in raw count, 2013 with 442 and 2010 with 445, both at 0.54 times the median, though neither drops into the low label. Then 2018 and 2009 follow at 0.71 and 0.72.

Cleanest on paper is still only paper. A single light year is thin evidence, and on a truck this old the service history carries more weight than the count. Recent model years are kept out of any clean list on principle, since a young truck has had little time to attract reports; every year in this run counts as settled, so none is cut.

Where the complaints land, system by system

Across all 15 years, six categories hold the largest piles of NHTSA complaints.

NHTSA categoryReports, whole run
Engine2,155
Electrical system1,939
Power train1,892
Service brakes1,807
Air bags1,695
Unknown or other1,404

Engine leads, but the numbers sit close enough that no single system dominates the record. A category is a bucket rather than a part: engine covers every kind of engine fault, the electrical system takes in the battery, wiring, lighting and control modules, and power train reaches past the transmission. A top ranking tells a mechanic where to start looking, not which component has failed. The unknown or other bucket carries no named system at all.

What to check on a truck from a flagged year

Match the inspection to the system that leads for the year in front of you.

  1. Ask for service records before anything else. On a pickup this old, a documented maintenance history says more than any model-year statistic.
  2. For a 2014: drive straight and through a tight turn, watch for steering warning lights, and note any change in steering effort.
  3. For a 2015: press the brake pedal firmly with the engine running, look for brake or anti-lock lights, and have a shop measure the rotors and pads with the wheels off.
  4. For a 2019: listen to a cold start and idle, check the oil and coolant, and have a scan tool read stored engine codes.
  5. For any year: test every window, lock, light and screen, then inspect the battery and its cables.
  6. Book a lift inspection with an independent mechanic, and set what they find beside the recall and title records for that VIN.

Why a zero in the recall column proves nothing

A recall and a complaint measure different things. A recall means the manufacturer has acknowledged a safety defect and published a remedy; a complaint is a single owner's report, taken as written. The recall column above comes from one data pull and is a rough guide at best.

That tally lists no recalls for 2017 through 2022, yet NHTSA's live recall listing for 2019 Silverado 1500 trucks names campaigns on tires, seat belts, brake power assist, battery cables, the driveshaft and a passenger air bag inflator. Neither number replaces a lookup on the actual truck.

A recall campaign covers a block of trucks built during a stretch of production, not every truck sharing a model year, so the VIN is the only dependable key. A dealer does the repair at no charge, but only within a federal limit: under 49 U.S.C. §30120(g), the no-charge duty does not apply when the first purchase came more than 15 calendar years before the recall notice, and tires carry a shorter limit.

Run the VIN, not the year

NHTSA's recall lookup takes the 17-character VIN and shows the campaigns that apply to that exact truck.

What the numbers cannot tell you

  • Volume: a popular year attracts more reports than a rare one of equal quality, which is why the median benchmark exists.
  • Time on the road: an older year has had longer to collect reports, so old and young years are not strictly comparable.
  • Accuracy: each complaint records what an owner believed happened, useful in bulk and shaky one at a time.
  • Individual trucks: every year holds well-kept examples and neglected ones, and the one in front of you is a VIN question.

Used well, the table decides where to look hard and how firmly to bargain. It never decides whether a particular truck is good.

Setting the Silverado beside other full-size pickups

Totals for rival pickups look larger or smaller, but they cover different year ranges and different sales volumes. NHTSA holds 19,248 complaints for the Ford F-150 over 2008 to 2022, 12,186 for the Ram 1500 over 2011 to 2022 and 5,544 for the GMC Sierra 1500 over 2009 to 2022. None of those totals ranks one truck above another. Compare shape instead: how far a model's worst year rises above its own median, and whether the heavy years cluster the way they do on the Silverado. A smaller total for a rival says nothing about the specific example you are shopping for, since a neglected truck turns up in every nameplate.

Checking the actual truck before you hand over money

A model year describes a population, and the truck on the lot is one member of it. Four checks belong to that truck alone.

  • NHTSA's recall lookup, which takes the VIN and lists open campaigns at no cost.
  • The NMVTIS title record, the national source for title history and brands.
  • NICB's VINCheck, a no-cost screen for theft and total-loss records.
  • A vehicle history report, which pulls accident, odometer, lien and salvage records together. This site's preview is free, and the full report is a one-time purchase.

Add a mechanic's lift inspection and you have enough to price the truck honestly.

Where this information comes from

  • NHTSA: Vehicle safety and complaints — Where owners file and search the complaint reports that make up the counts in the table.
  • NHTSA: Recalls — The VIN lookup for open campaigns, and the listing used to see which systems recalls touched on 2014 and 2019 trucks.
  • BJA: NMVTIS vehicle history — The federal title-record system, which covers one truck's title history where model-year data cannot.
  • NICB: VINCheck — A no-cost theft and total-loss screen run on a single VIN.

Sources and photos: Facts checked against the sources above in October 2026. Photo by Erik Mclean on Unsplash; diagrams by YourVINHistory.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

Which Chevrolet Silverado 1500 years should be avoided?

Going by NHTSA complaint volume, the 2014, 2015 and 2019 years draw the most attention, and 2008 sits next in line at 1.3 times the median without being flagged. None of that bans a truck. A flagged year with documented maintenance, a clean title and every recall performed can be a fair buy at the right price.

Is the 2012 Silverado 1500 the most dependable year?

It has the smallest complaint record at 359, but a count is not a reliability score, and one light year is thin evidence. A 2012 truck is also old enough that the federal no-charge recall duty can lapse for campaigns announced late. Check the VIN and the maintenance history rather than leaning on the model year.

What are the most common Silverado 1500 problems?

Engine complaints lead at 2,155, followed by the electrical system at 1,939 and power train at 1,892. Those are broad NHTSA buckets, so each covers many parts. For a specific truck, a scan for stored codes and a test drive that exercises the transmission, steering and brakes will tell you more than category totals.

How do I check a Silverado 1500 for open recalls?

Enter the 17-character VIN in NHTSA's recall lookup. Recalls follow production ranges rather than model years, so two trucks from the same year can differ. A dealer performs the repair at no charge within the federal age limit, so ask for paperwork showing completed campaigns before you buy.

Is a 2014 Silverado 1500 a bad buy?

Not automatically. The 2014 year has the heaviest complaint count, 1,606, and steering leads it, so test steering and brakes closely and confirm recall work. Compare asking prices against other 2014 trucks with full records, and treat any gap in the history as a reason to negotiate or walk.

Now check the car itself

The guide explains what to look for. The report shows what this VIN has on record.

Find the VIN on the driver's door jamb, at the base of the windshield, or on the registration and insurance card.